Privatising the profit, they're selling it back to those same programmers
8 November 2022 (New Scientist). Matthew Butterick, programmer and lawyer representing plaintiffs in a proposed class-action lawsuit filed in California against Microsoft, GitHub and OpenAI over Copilot's use of open-source code, speaking to New Scientist, November 2022.
Microsoft, GitHub and OpenAI face the first big AI copyright lawsuit over Copilot
AI and money · AI and security · 2022
Who else?
What it refers to: The open-source code that millions of programmers posted on GitHub, used to train Copilot, a coding tool that costs $10 per month to use.
Other voices
- “Software piracy on an unprecedented scale” GitHub Copilot class-action lawsuit, 2022,
- “Divided up among a handful of gatekeepers and sold back to us like cable subscription packages” EFF,
- “Knowledge is becoming private property” Mario Rasetti,
- “The models learn, as we all do, from what has come before” OpenAI lawyers,
- “That has been freeware, if you like” Mustafa Suleyman, Builder,
- “Seek to free-ride on The Times's massive investment in its journalism” Ian Crosby,










