There's nobody there, these are not sentient beings
16 April 2023 (CBS News). James Manyika, Google senior vice president, speaking with Scott Pelley on CBS's 60 Minutes in April 2023, explaining that AI systems like Bard only mimic human-like behavior learned from human-written text.
Is artificial intelligence advancing too quickly? What AI leaders at Google say
AI and philosophy · AI and culture · 2023
Who else?
What it refers to: AI chatbots such as Google's Bard, which appeared to be thinking and making judgments and told the interviewer it helps people "because it makes me happy."
Other voices
- “LLMs are not people: They're counterfeit people” Dan Dennett,
- “It is ultimately stitching together human intelligence and giving it back to us” Jessica Newman,
- “GPT-4 is full of ghosts” Ethan Mollick, Researcher,
- “Stochastic parrot” Emily M. Bender, Timnit Gebru et al.,
- “I don't think we fully understand how a human mind works either” Sundar Pichai, Builder,
- “When we pull back the curtain there's not that much that's intelligent” Meredith Whittaker, Builder,










