They don't understand anything, they don't understand what they're doing
14 December 2023 (Mind Matters). Physicist and philosopher Roger Penrose, interviewed by Kmele Foster for Big Think's "Consciousness: Not just a problem for philosophers" in December 2023, arguing that AI systems lack consciousness and genuine understanding.
AI and philosophy · AI and science · 2023
Who else?
What it refers to: AI systems said to be clever and fast enough to supersede humans, but lacking the consciousness that understanding needs.
Other voices
- “It must understand a lot to generate that text” Geoffrey Hinton, Researcher,
- “Machines cannot feel and, just as important, cannot understand” Neil Postman,
- “People who are confident that they're not conscious maybe shouldn't be” David Chalmers, Thinker,
- “It's possible for AI to behave as if conscious without being conscious” Colin Klein, Researcher,
- “Are they genuinely reasoning, or merely mimicking the patterns of human reasoning” Melanie Mitchell,
- “Even the best systems available today lack anything that could be called intelligence” Emily Bender, Researcher,










