Mindless toasters that do a lot of cognitive labor without thinking
11 December 2024 (Nautilus). Philosopher Shannon Vallor, in a Nautilus interview with Philip Ball about her book The AI Mirror, December 2024, describing large language models after criticizing Sam Altman's redefinition of AGI.
AI Is the Black Mirror - Nautilus | Science Connected
More from Shannon Vallor · AI and philosophy · AI and hype · 2024
Who else?
What it refers to: Large language models, set against Sam Altman's reframing of AGI as a machine that can do all of the economically valuable tasks that humans do.
Other voices
- “AGI kinda went whooshing by” Sam Altman, Builder,
- “Are they genuinely reasoning, or merely mimicking the patterns of human reasoning” Melanie Mitchell,
- “Stochastic parrot” Emily M. Bender, Timnit Gebru et al.,
- “Deep learning is going to be able to do everything” Geoffrey Hinton, Researcher,
- “LLMs are not people: They're counterfeit people” Dan Dennett,
- “People who are confident that they're not conscious maybe shouldn't be” David Chalmers, Thinker,










